h1

Just one in four blame the coalition for the cuts

June 14th, 2011

How long can Osborne go on blaming the “other lot”

The June “blame game index” from YouGov is out and has the proportion of those sampled blaming the coalition down two points on May to 24% – the lowest figure in 2011 since the first week in January.

The last Labour government, meanwhile, is blamed by 40% which is down a point but is still up 2% on what it was in March.

I think that this is a key measure and reflects the challenge that Labour is having getting its message over. It’s hard attacking the government when two out of five still blame them.

Mike Smithson




  • Ave it

    92 ‘Bad language, personal nastiness or posts that are overly long, tangential or simply tedious may be deleted and their authors may be subject to temporary or permanent bans.’

    Oooh glad we dont have that kind of behaviour here!

  • IoS

    Fitalass

    Did you even read the front page of the mirror before trying to get your comment in.

    You know they are actually having a go at Cameron for spending money on a never ending war!

  • Ave it

    92 ‘Note that asterisked swear words still read as swear words’

    what about # or ~

    :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

  • fitalass

    Ave it @99

    :D

    Have you seen the threads there these days, gave up posting the odd comment long ago. And the threads become unreadable.

  • Lucian Fletcher

    94 – The repeat of my appearance was on today I think so you might have caught that.

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b00c6xmc/Eggheads_Series_9_Episode_71/

    I have not knowingly been on anything since but my lovely new wife makes episodic cameos in her dad’s programme on BBCNI.

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b0103v9b/Dereks_Dreaming_Again_Episode_1

  • http://politicalbetting.com johnno

    100,did’t labour support it.

  • fitalass

    IoS @100

    I have just listened to the Skynews paper reviewers discussing it!! You didn’t even bother to add a link either.

  • Ave it

    102 because of all the asterisks?!

    :lol:

  • Peter from Putney

    94 BTW Judith Keppel from Eggheads (and the first “Millionaire” winner) is 69 in two months’ time……. wearing well that’s for sure.

  • Mick Pork

    Obama had a fair wind for a couple of years because he was left with an economic disaster.

    Not any more.

  • IoS

    Fitalass

    So what has no money left got to do with defending the front page?

  • antifrank

    The headline is incorrect: 48% of the public blame the coalition for the cuts to some extent. Only 24% of them blame the coalition exclusively, but another 24% place some blame at their door.

    The hard figure is that 64% blame Labour to some extent. This figure is very stable. This is where Labour have most work to do.

  • fitalass

    Lucian Fletcher @103

    I hadn’t realised you had appeared on this programme!! My Mum and my Aunt are huge fans of it. So a PBeer on Eggheads and Chris A was on mastermind. Impressive. Wasn’t another regular on the Krypton Factor as well?

  • Oracle

    “Giggs brother cheated on wife while wife cheated on him with Giggs”

    Eyes pops out of head….

  • Peter from Putney

    103 94 – The repeat of my appearance was on today I think so you might have caught that.

    Precisely – a pretty good memory of mine don’t you think?

  • Lucian Fletcher

    I’d not heard that. I used to love Krypton Factor.

  • fitalass

    IoS @109

    Quite a lot if you bother to follow the detail rather than the Mirror’s spin on it.

  • IoS

    Fitalass

    No go on. I would like you to explain.

  • Witan

    PfP the local fat cats need sorting but it is their employers, not the government, who have to do it.

    Who voted for a local councillor recently who is not committed to removing these leeches?

    I suppose it is easier to blame the government – this or any other government – rather than ourselves.

  • Peter from Putney

    114 I used to love Krypton Factor.

    As won last year by Aaron of this Parish!

  • Lucian Fletcher

    113 – Pretty impressive :)

  • fitalass

    IoS @116:

    Fitalass

    No go on. I would like you to explain.

    I highlighted this story on the early morning thread yesterday with links and quotes from two articles. And all without the Mirror’s comedy front page a day late for help thanks.  

  • tim
  • fitalass

    Peter from Putney @118:

    114 I used to love Krypton Factor.

    As won last year by Aaron of this Parish!

    Thanks Peter, I was sure that a PBeer had taken part in the programme.  

  • jascow

    chris_g00 @27
    We might as well have Ed Miliband as PM if he does.

  • tim

    LOL, u turns and slop buckets.

    http://tinyurl.com/426dkmr

  • tpfkar

    I had no idea there were so many game show celebrities here, I’ll ask for autographs at the next meetup. I think my appearance on Brainteaser in 2006 will put me near the back of the queue though.

  • fitalass
  • John F

    100

    ‘You know they are actually having a go at Cameron for spending money on a never ending war!’

    Has the Mirror already forgotten that Afghanistan has been running for 11 years and that was Labour’s war?

  • chris_g00

    John F @126
    I’ve no problem with Britain fighting any just war – so long as we properly fund our armed forces. The Libyan adventure as highlighted what a shambles the Strategic Defence Review was, no wonder Fox considered resigning.

  • chris_g00

    HAS highlighted**

  • Sunil Prasannan

    Peter from Putney

    Eggheads this week seem to be episodes from 2008! I think they were a bit more recent in previous weeks. The Challenge channel (Freeview 46) show the odd episode from 2007.

  • John F

    127

    Switch resources from Afghanistan which after 11 years of going nowhere is clearly a complete waste of time.

  • jascow

    For the sake of 100 million quid, a mere rounding error in the enormous scales of government spending, I can’t believe they’ve allowed another U-Turn on bin collections. And more ECHR madness in the Telegraph.

  • Peter from Putney

    129 Small wonder then that La Keppel looked so good for her age!

  • Peter from Putney

    130 Might as well, the Americans by all accounts think we’ve been a waste of space there. If that’s how little appreciation our troops receive, why stay?

  • toryorange

    OK, here’s a test:

    Thanks fitalass @92

  • Sunil Prasannan

    129. Sorry Lucien I ddin’t pay too much attention to today’s Eggheads episode so didn’t actually recognise you. :eek: Well done for taking part!

  • jascow

    toryorange @134
    Did you do the HTML code for the hyperlink yourself? Edmund in Tokyo has kindly produced a widget to do it automatically by inserting a reply link under every post!

    http://edmundintokyo.wordpress.com/2010/04/08/a-more-efficient-way-to-waste-time-on-politicalbetting-com-firefox-only/

    Works in Firefox and Chrome.

  • fitalass

    chris_g00 @127:

    I’ve no problem with Britain fighting any just war – so long as we properly fund our armed forces. The Libyan adventure as highlighted what a shambles the Strategic Defence Review was, no wonder Fox considered resigning.

    Considering it was the first one in years, and with the severe financial restrictions that were in place as well as a complete Omnishambles of a procurement overspend. I am at a complete loss as to why anyone thought it would not cause an outcry what ever decisions were taken.

    Sometimes there are simple no easy or popular ways to sort out a complete mess, and nothing shows that more than the SDR or the Budget that Osborne had to deliver when faced with that Deficit/Debt he inherited from the Last Labour government. The current mess at the MOD was a very long time in the making, and was another classic example of Labour’s burnt earth strategy before leaving Office. Something not shouted loudly enough or often enough now.

  • Lucian Fletcher

    135 – I didn’t watch it myself. Just a couple of facebook comments led me to know the repeat was on.

  • Peter from Putney

    136 Sunil – he was the good-looking one in the middle who got the easy questions!

  • fitalass

    toryorange @134

    You are welcome toryorange. :D

  • Sunil Prasannan

    112. “Giggs brother cheated on wife while wife cheated on him with Giggs”

    Who dares swings?

  • fitalass

    I like the idea of Peter Capaldi as the voice over for the Tesco mobiles ads. :D

  • Peter from Putney

    141 Boy – is he going to get some stick from away crowds next season.

  • Peter from Putney

    141 Boy – is he going to get some stick from away crowds next season.

  • Peter from Putney

    Oops, sorry for the duplicate posting.

  • John F

    133

    First we were going to defeat Al Queda,then it was to educate girls,then give the Afghans a constitution,then introduce democracy,then defeat the drugs trade,not to mention the various infrastructure projects,get rid of the Taliban and allow the Afghan government to pass laws to legalise rape in marriage.

    And that was just some of New Labour’s objectives for Afghanistan 11 years ago,billions of taxpayers money spent and massive sacrifices from our troops.

    Anyone got a clue what’s been achieved and why we should be there any longer?

  • Peter from Putney

    Goodnight all.

  • chris_g00

    fitalass @137
    We could have abolished Overseas Aid, refused to bail out Euro Countries, stopped wasting money on ‘green’ projects.

    We have no strategic interest in Afghanistan. It’s not worth the life of one British soldier. As for Libya, strategic interest is minimal, and has just served to highlight our weakness. We beg the Americans to keep us in a special relationship, I’m at a loss as to why they will for much longer as we degrade our own capability.

  • Sunil Prasannan

    139. PfP

    Looking at the iPlayer link in post 103, I know why I didn’t recognise Lucien – I’m pretty sure he wore glasses at the PB bash in April – am I right?

  • The Screaming Eagles

    143/144 – He’s a legend in Wales.

    For the first time in living memory, jokes about a Welshman having sex don’t involve sheep.

  • Lucian Fletcher

    149 – Everyone here has such a good memory. I do usually wear glasses nowadays. Though I went without for wedding pics. I must post a link to one when I get a min.

  • fitalass

    chris_g00 @148

    You don’t see over seas aid, or the vaccination programme in particular, as being absolutely vital to countries abroad and us at home on so many fronts?

  • Peter from Putney

    149 I’m pretty sure he wore glasses at the PB bash in April – am I right?

    I can’t say – I wasn’t there. I was simply relying on my memory of his mugshot from two years ago – although I couldn’t remember the questions he was asked. Hence my original thought that he had made a further “guest appearance”.

  • Neil

    150 – “For the first time in living memory, jokes about a Welshman having sex don’t involve sheep.”

    They do in a hilarious version I heard…

  • Sunil Prasannan

    151. Hi Lucien, yes I am reasonably good remembering faces! Not sure if you remember me!

  • Pulpstar

    @146 With Bin Laden having been killed and the Taliban ousted from power we most certainly should withdraw now. Are we all out of Iraq yet ?
    As for Libya, we need to oust Gaddaffi similiarly to how Gbagbo was outed in Ivory Coast, hes got British blood on his hands and thats good enough for me.

  • chris_g00

    fitalass @152
    It’s great the private individuals are helping those in need, more power to them. However, I think it’s immoral to force people on the minimum wage here in the UK on pain of imprisonment to share that view.

    If you want to give to the third world, go ahead. Of the £60 million given to Uganda, £30 million was spent on a Presidential Jet. If I can see the dangers of welfare at home, I would hardly want to inflict it on people abroad. For as long as we pick up the bills of failed central governments in third world states, nothing will change.

  • The Screaming Eagles

    154 – You have to share it now Neil, it is past the lagershed after all.

  • Lucian Fletcher

    155 – I do actually. I’m not bad at recalling people from PB dos.

    I’ve stuck a wedding pic as my FB profile. Not sure how well people will be able to see.

    https://www.facebook.com/daveroedj/posts/187289061289438#!/daveroedj

  • Peter from Putney

    155 If not the spelling of [adopted] names!

  • Pulpstar

    Some interesting science here for the global warming debate: http://www.theregister.co.uk/2011/06/14/ice_age/ also check the research on wind farms thats on a related page.

  • Neil

    158 – I’m afraid I was bluffing. Though if one comes to me in my sleep I will post it tomorrow (after the lagershed!). Night!

  • Sunil Prasannan

    160. PfP

    Ooops! Sorry, Lucian

  • LondonStatto

    Latecomer to this thread but I always try to comment on this subject – the number blaming Labour to some degree remains remarkably consistently in the low 60s, where it’s been for the best part of a year.

    Surely EdM can’t win without getting that number below 50%.

  • http://edmundintokyo.wordpress.com Edmund in Tokyo

    LondonStatto @164:

    Surely EdM can’t win without getting that number below 50%.

     

    Thanks to the magic of FPTP, he can.

    That said, getting the number below 50% by 2015 doesn’t sound like a big ask.

  • another richard

    FPT Sean Fear:

    “Hampstead isn’t Inner London, and would have gone Conservative without boundary changes that favoured Labour.

    The problem was the London-wide result, not the Inner London result. The Conservatives do reasonably well in Inner London. It’s Outer London where the problem lies. But, I do take your point, that the Conservatives spent ages trying to win posh left wingers over who hated them, and still voted against them, while neglecting people lower down the scale.

    That cost them their majority. Cameron is awkward with C1s C2s in a way that Thatcher and Tebbit never were.”

    Hampstead is Inner London, its in Camden.

    Now granted the constituency is Hampstead and Kilburn and Kilburn is in Brent (and so Outer London) but the larger part is Hampstead and Kilburn itself is rather urban trendy. And yes the Conservatives were ahead in the Hampstead section but without Kilburn (which up to the election had a LibDem MP in Sarah Teather) the constituency would have been a 2 way marginal rather than 3 way, to the advantage of Labour.

    The Conservatives did reasonably well vote wise in Inner London but gained no seats apart from Battersea which was a foregone conclusion. And its seats that count. The result was especially disappointing to them as so much effort had been put into the likes of Hammersmith, Tooting and Westminster N where they had high profile ‘Tatler Tory’ candidates. Picking up an extra thousand votes in Islington or Streatham achieved nothing for the Conservatives especially as this tended to be at the expense of gaining extra votes in the midlands and north where it would have been much more useful.

    The results in Outer London weren’t actually too bad for the Conservatives with gains in Harrow E, Hendon, Finchley, Enfield N, Ealing Acton, Brentford and Richmond Park. The Conservatives doing okay in the outer ring of constituencies but very poorly in the half way out seats such as Ealing N, Brent N, Ilford S and Eltham, places where demographic change has been significant. The only really disappointing defeat for the Conservatives in Outer London was Eltham (another constituency which had a candidate from the chosen few).

    As to the appeal of Cameron – I don’t blame him for his lack of natural appeal to the C1s and C2s as his background is so different to theirs (while Thatcher and Tebbit came from them). What does deserve blame though is Cameron’s seeming preference for surrounding himself with people of a similar background and for continually thinking that everybody shares the same interests as him.

  • GeoffM

    165 EiT Getting it below 50% is very likely because a good percentage of the public have goldfish-like memories.

    Doesn’t stop it being true though.

  • HD2

    The answer to the thread question is:
    At least 10 years, probably a lot more – say until the additional;debt accumulated over their 13 years in power is entirely paid off (say – 2040).

    ‘Labour bankrupted the country yet again – keep them out for ever’ is a powerful message and will last at least until the next global recession is over and forgotten about.

  • The rev

    The coalition have played a blinder in persuading the general public that labour are responsible for the cuts. [aside: I do wonder as to whether or not getting this view across has done damage to consumer confidence and in turn the economy]

    This view seems so entrenched – difficult for labour to turn around even if the truth of it is debatable.

  • http://www.croydonloony.co.uk JohnLoony

    Yellow.

  • http://www.croydonloony.co.uk JohnLoony

    The article at the top of the thread means that 24% of people are insane. Only 40% are reasonable, logical and normal.

    ———–

    Somebody “The income of UK solicitors is now £14,000,000,000 pa.”

    What, each?

    ————-

    “QTWTAIN” is pronounced “quain”. I think that “QTWTAIY” is probably pronounced “qwhy”.

    ———–

    The video clip of the stroppy doctor getting annoyed at the journalists not following proper procedure (in having their sleeves rolled up and ties off) is confusing because there are one or two awkward edit/cut points where there is obviously a bit missing.

  • Freggles

    chris_g00 @148

    The interest in Afghanistan is that they are next door to Pakistan, and if the terrorists think they’ve won in Afghanistan they might just turn their attentions to Pakistan. Nuclear weapon in hands of non-state elements: not good

  • tim

    Morning, Coalitionista bin men, hows yer slop buckets this morning?

    Here we are seeing the costs of a govt led by a lazy Etonian, and policed by Oliver Letwin, Etonian author of the poll tax.

    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/health/healthnews/8575702/Red-tape-fears-in-reshaped-NHS-reforms.html

  • Mike Smithson

    Gabble @92
    Correct – The first poll of 2011 has the coalition blame figure on 22%. I’ve amended the header.

  • HD2

    The Poll Tax was a good idea: its implementation (particularly in charging for non-working wives @ 100%) was deeply flawed.

    The Inland Revenue opposed the tax, so made its rules problematic.

    Its two primary aims were achieved – make users pay for Council services and remove many Labour voters from the electoral roll, since if you did so, you’d avoid paying the tax.

    Bin tax (like Eire) anyone? Why not pay per bin, with massive penalties for fly-tipping?

  • HD2

    HD2 @178
    Me – taxing houses is easy, though, since avoiding the tax is all but impossible.

    Local councils (counties?) should have their own sales taxes, though, in exchange for all but scrapping the Central Govt grant.

  • antifrank

    Andrew Grice (wasted at the Independent) has posted an intriguing article this morning:

    http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/first-his-brother-now-milibands-at-war-with-balls-2297553.html

    The argument at the centre of this is a very interesting strategic one, with force on both sides. On balance I agree with Ed Balls.

  • http://twitter.com/PlatoSays Plato

    http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/news/julianastle/100092232/this-scalp-hunting-could-destroy-the-lib-dems/

    As the leader of a party with no hope of winning an outright majority at the next election, he can’t afford for coalition to become a by-word for fractious or divided government. If voters are determined to avoid another hung parliament in 2015, the Lib Dems could be squeezed almost out of existence.

    Until recently, the good reputation of coalition politics seemed secure; relations between the governing parties were harmonious at the top, constructive and businesslike further down. Not so today. The relationship between the Prime Minister and his deputy has cooled, just as the relationship between their parties has become dangerously overheated. Reports of Conservative MPs shouting “Let’s get the yellow bastards!” at a meeting of the backbench 1922 committee underline just how bad things have become.

    Unsurprisingly, this is having an impact on public attitudes. A recent study by the Institute for Government think tank found that, after strong early support for the idea of parties working together in coalitions, a majority of voters have now turned against it, believing single-party governments to be stronger, more decisive and less confused. This may not concern the Conservatives; it should scare the pants off the Lib Dems.

     

  • http://twitter.com/PlatoSays Plato

    Plato @181:

    By far the biggest danger for the Lib Dems, as they seek to distance themselves from their coalition partners, is that they slip into a lazy, oppositionist mindset, thus relinquishing the chance eventually to claim credit for the tough decisions the Government is taking. One Lib Dem minister recently likened his party to a difficult-to-steer supermarket trolley, warning: “unless you constantly pull it the other way, it will veer leftwards and crash”.

     

  • fr

    “Hospitals in the West Midlands have been exposed for trying to hide the true level of deaths on their wards.

    Stafford and Walsall hospitals declared hundreds of extra patients as being terminally ill in order to remove their deaths from the hospital mortality rates – making the trusts look like they were delivering better care.

    The number of patients designated as “terminal” by bosses at Walsall Manor Hospital increased from around 10 per cent to 78 per cent of all deaths, during a six-month period in 2008.

    Meanwhile, at Stafford the figures shot up from around 10 per cent to 35 per cent. The revelations emerged at the public inquiry into poor standards at Stafford Hospital which heard evidence from death rates expert Professor Sir Brian Jarman.

    He also told the inquiry that more than 20,000 people may have died as a result of poor care at hospitals across the West Midlands over the past 13 years.”

    Read more: http://www.expressandstar.com/news/2011/06/14/hospitals-in-deaths-cover-up/#ixzz1PKEHtPq4

  • HD2

    fr @183
    NHS – ‘The envy of the world’.
    Or not.

  • Ben Elford

    HD2 @178
    Agree with you on the rightness, in principle, of the community charge; not sure that removing Labour voters from the register was ever an aim.

    On fly tipping, you can make the fines as massive as you like but without enforcement there’s really no point. As it is, police forces often don’t take crimes such as burglary seriously. I can imagine the conversation when trying to report a mattress left in a lay-by (after two days trying to get through on the phone) “And just how is this affecting you, sir?”

  • http://twitter.com/PlatoSays Plato

    fr @183:

    more than 20,000 people may have died as a result of poor care

     

    WTF???

    By saying they were terminal when they weren’t!!

    It makes Harold Shipman look positively restrained.

  • DavidL

    Good article by Matthew Norman summarising well what I have been thinking about David Miliband:
    http://www.independent.co.uk/opinion/commentators/matthew-norman/matthew-norman-shame-on-david-miliband-for-dragging-his-party-down-2297369.html

    There are definite elements of the Heath huff here. If he is not going to play he should get out sharpish and get a real job.

  • Fat Steve

    antifrank @180
    That is an interesting article.
    Ed Balls is an intriguing figure – I was going to say divisive figure, but not really, the world seems to be divided into those don’t trust him, and Yvette Cooper.
    If Ed Milliband wanted to promote some non-Ballsian economic thinking, I wonder how that would play out.

  • http://twitter.com/PlatoSays Plato
  • fr

    He also told the inquiry that more than 20,000 people may have died as a result of poor care at hospitals across the West Midlands over the past 13 years.”

    Labour’s NHS legacy. Don’t let lazy Letwin ruin it.

  • Richard 111

    176. Looks as though Oliver Letwin must have changed his name by deed poll. The poll tax came from the work of Lord Rothschild, William Walegrave and Kenneth Baker in 1986 although it was originally considered in a Green Paper in 1981 when the real Oliver Letwin appears to be working in America.

    Alternatively, timmy is having another of his flights of fancy. Perhaps he should really be trying to understand how the Shadow CoE was the real author of introducing and then abolishing the 10p tax rate, abolishing “boom and bust” and designing the tripartite system of regulation that collapse in a heap when tested.

  • Mike Smithson

    New thread
    Will the coalition’s resolve hold against the teachers? http://bit.ly/kslE90

  • fr

    To enable the Labour Party to tell the big lie over the NHS, it is necessary first to get the intimidated bureaucrats to tell 20,000 “little” lies.

  • HD2

    Ben Elford @185
    I agree entirely with the point re fly-tipping. I can see charging for bin collection (as in Eire) makes fly-tipping a more attractive option, so we need to prevent that.

    I’d like to see the industrial ‘dumpy’ bins on the end of each street, collected every night or two, so that dumping rubbish there would be ‘free’, whilst household bins could be emptied whenever you put them out (say, a specified day per week) with a charge per bin.

    Compared to 30 years ago, we, the public, are doing 99.99% of the work that used to be done by Bin men and/or staff at recycling centres.

    Over the same time, councils have taxed us much more and received greater central Govt grants: in short, we are paying more and getting less – hence public anger.

    The ‘keep Labour voters off the electoral roll’ was never an explicit aim, but was a fortunate, and entirely foreseeable, consequence. That suggests it was not unexpected and not unwelcome!